Played this on PS2 and WE10, and... It's improved, but WE10 is masterful.
Something that says a lot - the last three or four WE's that have come out, I've played once, started to patch and never played again. WE10 I have been playing solidly since my copy arrived, and I haven't been on my XBOX 360 in a WEEK. I have never played a football game as good as this.
Sorry, but FIFA will always be "amazing" for the first few days, then when you realise that it's a dog turd in makeup, you'll switch back to WE. This time last year I was praising FIFA to the heavens ("it's got Tranmere, it's got a real league mode, it's got tons of stadiums, it's so much fun"), and it WAS fun. Until I realised I played the same game of football every time I picked the pad up, same kind of passes, shots, scores.
The "individual team styles" in WE10 (meaning certain teams ping the ball around all day, others attack VENOMOUSLY, others defend for their life), is what I've dreamt of for a long time. You could play three teams, all in black kits, and know who they are from the way they play. Fantastic stuff.
So, FIFA - it's alright for a while, but I'll tell you what lads, when you get PES6, you won't look back.