Flipper the Priest
International
- 15 July 2003
This discussion is so silly both on this pes forum and on the fifa forum, first of all, from what I've read so far, no game has had anyone thank everyone lol, many talk about pes 5, 4, 6 which were more responsive or real games in I actually wanted to know how many of you have played football, because I played semi-amateur for 15 years and I can say that those loose and fast movements of old feet are quite unreal, in fact impossible to do, I say that the rigidity of modern or recent FIFA feet and Much more plausible than the freedom of old feet, I believe that there are a lot of older people here who have that attachment and a bit of nostalgia, which is why they will never exchange their old feet for a FIFA 25 or new feet! Another thing is that no one here can say that one game is better or more realistic than another, as these are only opinions and there will never be absolute certainty, if I say that ea fc 24 is more realistic than any old game in terms of variety or movement be more real because people are not as agile as those old feet who will have the absolute reason to contradict me lol, that's why this discussion will never end and there will never again be a modern game that will please the majority, one by one old games are easier and another because of our age!
Of course it's all opinion. That's the treachery of internet forums and always has been! For example you say the rigidity of players in modern FIFA. I'd say the problem is they aren't rigid enough, and that they move like they have no skeleton and don't adhere to the laws of friction.
I'd also say that nostalgia may play a part for some, but it has to be remembered that people are still playing the old games. It's not just rosy memories. There people actively playing both old and new, and drawing direct comparisons. I'd say I've played most of if not all the PES games from Goal Storm to 2021 and eFootball within the past year. Some things are relative to the time. eFootball's animations are, for example, better than ISS Pro Evolution's. But ISS Pro Evolution's were far better for 1999 than eFootball's are for 2024. But some things are simply better or worse to me, free from the effects of time. Like the AI variety is better in PES 2008 for PS2 than it is PES 2021, whether it's 2007, 2020, or 2064.
But of course it's all futile. What we say/do/type has fuck all effect on the games and we're all basically bald strangers fighting over a comb! 😄