Re: Serie A Thread - 2009/10 Season
edmundo said:
A very poor advert for the Italian league, thankfully Inter's performance 2 miles away 48 hours earlier (and Fiorentina's games vs Bayern) demonstrated that Italian football still has some strength.
pfff... anyone who pretends to extrapolate a fair opinion from a champions league or an europa league matchup is a hopeless idiot whose opinions don't deserve any attention.... so i don't really bother about that.
single matches are everything but a reliable source of info... and european matchups are the most unreliable among the single matches competitions....
i could prove everything.... and its contrary, by using single matches result.
i could easily say that italian top teams are going through a decline.... the only real "top team" is inter right now (milan has been doing very good this season, but they're not a top notch team: roma is an amazing team with world class quality and technique, but, as a whole, they're not top class team: juventus isn't even a team, let alone a top class one).
yet i could also use jumbo's post in the last page to prove the exact opposite point.
the 10th team in premiership beated the 5th in serie a....but then again juventus is right now the worst team in the league, right after siena, atalanta and lazio (despite their current 5th place), while fulham is beyond any doubt the most underrated team in premiership, guided by the most underrated english coach.... yeah they might be the 10th club in the table, but football-wise, they're the 5th best team in england, from what i saw in the last 2 seasons.
it's pretty much the same with fiorentina and liverpool. fiorentina is 10th in serie a (just like fulham), while liverpool is 5th (just like juve)... and exactly as it happens for juve and fulham, both fiorentina and liverpool are now in a table position that doesn't really reflect their actual quality. fiorentina has been playing pretty good this season (much better than juve, for instance, which still is 5 spots ahead of fiorentina), and liverpool is just as embarassing and depressing as juve (and both juve and liverpool are in the 5th place, despite being among the poorest teams in their leagues, football wise).
so edmundo don't bother about "the image" a league offers from european matchups.... people will always see what they wanna see.... it's not a matter of proofs, it's all a matter of perception.
the 10th italian club beats the 5th english club?
oh, well, the thing is liverpool is just having a bad season.... it's not like this should prove anything.
but what's the reaction when the 10th english club beats the 5th italian club?
oh boy that's the clear proof of how bad italian football is today.... they can't even compete with a shitty team like fulham
u see what i mean? people who pretends to express judgement over european matchups don't really deserve any sort of credit or attention....and since they are the only ones who will "buy" this "poor advert", i couldn't really care less.
let's just take a look at some of this week end matches.
palermo-inter. palermo is really a nice team but no one would ever say they're a top class team who can compete with inter..... yet i'm quite confident inter won't win.
samp-juve. comparing samp to juve theese days is like comparing an alfa romeo to a vauxhall. sampdoria is a very nice team, composed, balanced, organized, with a very well defined style of play and some great players. juventus just has the great players.... and it's precisely because of their great players that they manage to get 1 point ahead of samp....but as a team, juve doesn't exist.
and yet despite the huge quality gap between sampdoria and juventus, juve might actually get a good result tomorrow (a draw or even a win).
inter is a better team than palermo and samp is a better team than juve..... that won't change if both palermo and juve will get a good result this week (wich might well happen). anyone who would consider palermo and juve better than inter and samp just coz of a single result, would be nothing more than an idiot...... aswell as anyone who would use the fulham-juve game to argue about the state of italian football.
----------------------------------------------------------------
speaking of serie a, quite an interesting week end this one
fiorentina-genoa
palermo-inter
roma-udinese
milan-napoli
samp-juve
each of theese matches could completely change the shape of the table.
inter 59
milan 58
roma 53
palermo 46
juve 45
samp 44
genoa 42
napoli 41
if inter doesn't win and milan beats napoli, then milan gets on top of the table.
if napoli beats milan and either samp or genoa don't win, then napoli get in the europa league zone.
if juve wins and palermo doesn't win, juve gets in the champions league zone.
if samp beats juve and palermo loses to inter, than samp gets into the champions league and palermo drops in the europa league zone.
if samp-juve ends with a draw and genoa beats fiorentina, then genoa gets the europa league, while samp is out of both champions league and europa league.
if samp and genoa win and palermo loses, then samp gets into the champions league zone, palermo drops to the europa league zone, genoa jumps to the europa league zone and juve falls into 7th spot (wich means no champions and no europa league).
as we use to say here in sicily.... minchia!

(wich may be translated with a "holy shit"!)
and u also have to take into account that lazio, fiorentina and udinese are having a bad season... coz normally those teams would be in this huge group too.